Decided to do my bathroom from ideas online so utilizing, as I call it "Spoils of Thrift Store War", here are my results. First I started with a clean slate.

 

As a rental there isn't much I can do in the way of wall color or plumbing fixtures. This seafoam green shower tiles are just gonna have to be hidden away. The floor tiles are a matte gray and white so I decided on the that color scheme.

 
Finished results. I actually changed pulls on the cabinet to white encircled with silver as the Goldtone made the look off to me.
2 Standard White Towels $2.50 each (Clearance)
2 Gray Wash Cloths $1
Fingertip Towel $5 (Rose's)
Shower Curtain w/ Roller Rings $10 (Rose's)
Marbled Oval Bowl $6 (Walmart)
Soap Pump $1 (Salvation Army Thrift)
Lotion Pump $2  (Walmart)
Tall Lid Jar for Cotton Swabs $1 (Salvation Army Thrift)
Glass Flower Vase as Tissue Caddy $3 (Local Thrift)
Ceramic Oil Burner $1 (Local Thrift)
Cabinet Pulls $6 (Walmart)
Bath Mats $2.50 each (Rose's)

Inside shower:
Water Bottle for Bubble Bath $1 (Walmart)
Hibiscus & Clay Scented Body Wash $1 (Dollar Store)
Covered Soap Dish 30¢ (Local Thrift)
Rounded Jar with Lid $1.50 (Local Thrift)
Lavender Bath Salt in Jar $1 (Dollar Store)

I hope to later add some decorative mirrors to the wall and perhaps a floating shelf/cabinet over the toilet.